Best Brown Eyeliner: Naturally Subtle or Big Time Drama!
Create the best looks with this modern take on eyeliner. Brown is the new black. Enhance your natural look or bring on the drama with these gems!
If you’re looking to add a pop of drama and definition to your eyes - wear brown eyeliner! It's definitely the way to go. From subtle, everyday looks that only require a light dusting of soft cocoa color along your lash line, to bolder winged types with deep espresso shades that make an unforgettable style impact—brown eyeliner can do it all!
Finding the perfect one for your unique style can be tricky; let us help you narrow down the best products and give you some tips on getting perfectly lined eyes every time!
We hope you discover your next favorite beauty find from the list below! Each product was independently selected by our editors. Some may have been sent as samples for us to try, but all opinions in this article are our own. And, FYI — GlamourBadger may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy something (that's how we stay in business). Reviews have been edited for length and clarity. Enjoy your next favorite beauty find!
How We Choose
We know that finding the best eyeliner can be tough. That’s why we read through thousands of verified customer reviews to find you the highest-rated setting brown eyeliners for you. Whether you’re looking for a matte finish or one with a little shimmer, we’ve got the perfect liner for you.
Stop wasting time testing out every eyeliner at your local department store - find your perfect match here! With so many finishes to choose from, we know you’ll find the perfect one for your unique look.
Keep reading to find our top picks!
Why We Like It
Take your eye look to the next level with Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner! This #1 selling waterproof liner allows you to create beautiful, dramatic looks without worrying about smudging and running. Whether you’re looking to trace thin, precise lines or bold, daring strokes, this amazing product helps you achieve an eye-catching look.
This formula glides on easily and dries quickly so there’s no need to worry about your eye makeup fading away throughout the day. The best part? Stila's waterproof liquid eyeliner will last from day to night and won't leave your eyes looking anything but perfect! Get ready for breathtaking eyes any time of day with this brown liquid eyeliner—your trusted go-to for long-lasting, fashionable flair!
More to Know
Achieve that perfectly-defined eye look with ease with this must-have tool in your makeup arsenal. The marker-like tip ensures precise application, from a thin line to a bolder look. Best of all, the ink goes on smoothly without any smudging or running!
Newcomers won't have to worry about getting it wrong - simply shake the pen well before use, sweep it along your lashline, and intensify color if desired. To ensure consistently great performance, store the pen horizontally when you're done for the day.
Best Versatility
Pencil Eyeliner by Revlon, ColorStay Eye Makeup with Built-in Sharpener
Why We Like It
Say goodbye to fading, smudging, and transferring eyeliner, and say hello to the new ColorStay Eye Makeup from Revlon with a built-in sharpener! This cult-classic pencil eyeliner is loved by beauty mavens all over and now you can get it in an updated, waterproof formula that glides on smoothly.
With up to 24 hours of wear, you don’t have to worry about retouching your eyes mid-day or evening. Just draw on your favorite look and it will stay put! Plus, with a twistable base that includes an integrated sharpener in the slim design, you always have an ultra-precise application ready at any time. Perfect for novices or professional makeup lovers, you won’t regret this Pencil Eyeliner from Revlon. Get out there and face the day with perfect eyes each and every time!
More to Know
If you're looking for an easy way to add some drama to your look, then look no further than the amazing product which has a built-in sharpener and smudger! With its help, it's now easier than ever to create a number of beautiful eyeliner looks - from defined shapes like a cat eye or winged liner to a more dramatically smoldering and smoky finish.
Achieve precision lines with no fuss, thanks to this great product. So why not make your life easier and give yourself instant glamour with a stroke of this eyeliner?
Why We Like It
Interested in giving your eyes a subtle pop of definition? Get ready to be wowed by Pacifica Beauty’s Natural Eye Pencil! Whether you’re going for a soft and delicate or bold and daring look, we’ve got your eye makeup needs covered. This natural eyeliner pencil features an incredibly buttery smooth application that glides onto the lash line easily.
The formula is made with nourishing ingredients such as jojoba oil, shea butter, vitamin E, and vitamin C, making it wonderfully organic, vegan-friendly, and good for sensitive skin. Show off those beautiful eyes without compromising on quality – try out Pacifica Beauty’s Natural Eyeliner Pencil today!
More to Know
Shopping for makeup can be an overwhelming experience - especially when it comes to trying to find formulas free of parabens, phthalates, and all the other ingredients you try so hard to avoid. Well, we’re here to make your search a little easier!
This natural formula offers long-lasting wear - so no need for touch-ups throughout the day - and has beneficial ingredients that are extra gentle on the sensitive eye area. On top of that, this product is vegan and cruelty-free – so you can feel comfortable knowing you’re treating yourself without harming animals in the process.
Why We Like It
Instantly upgrade your eyeliner game with NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick, a powerfully pigmented eyeliner stick that delivers sleek, stylish, and long-lasting color. This lightweight pencil glides on smoothly to create graphic eye looks and gives you 36 hours of waterproof and smudge-proof results.
From subtle feminine eyeliner styles to dramatically daring looks that last through the night – this versatile liner stick provides modern makeup perfection for any occasion. We know you love fabulous eye looks as much as we do, so let the waterproof Epic Wear Liner Stick be your trusted sidekick!
More to Know
NYX's Epic Wear Liner Stick is impressive and longer lasting than ever before. The metallic matte finish is truly something special that will have heads turning.
This eyeliner pencil is vegan and cruelty-free. (We also love the NYX epic ink liner for that same reason.) So now, you can get that look you've been aiming for without any of the guilt! Get ready to show off your dazzling eyes in all the right ways.
Why We Like It
Get ready for drama with Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner! With this super-concentrated oil-free gel eyeliner, you can create a smudge-proof, waterproof look that will last up to 24 hours. This liner has been reinvented with a clear gel base that holds highly concentrated pigments for the most intense and dramatic liner yet.
And best of all, it's ophthalmologist-tested, dermatologist tested and allergy tested; making it suitable for even sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. So go ahead and show off your inner diva with bold lines or subtle cat eyes thanks to Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner!
More to Know
Whether your look calls for a subtle daytime cat eye to highlight those beautiful eyes or a more intense sultry smoky eye for evening, this gel liner will help you get your desired outcome. It is formulated with highly concentrated pigments so that color pops and wears off even after hours of wear. It's smudge-proof and water-resistant – perfect for an unpredictable weather day.
Just follow three simple steps – use liner to make small dots along the lash line, connect the dots and then allow to dry before blinking – and you will be a pro at eyeliner application, creating custom looks that fit your style all day long!
Best Brown Eyeliner FAQs
Brown eyeliner can be a tricky thing to shop for. You want something that will look natural and enhance your eyes, but you don't want to end up with something that's the wrong color or doesn't last long.
It can be tough to find the best brown eyeliner for your needs. Do you want a pencil, liquid, or gel liner? What about waterproof or smudge-proof? How do you choose the right color?
Our list of the best brown eyeliners takes all of these factors into account. Plus, we've answered some of the most frequently asked questions on the topic so that you can make an informed decision before buying.
Who should wear brown eyeliner?
People with light brown eyes and warm skin tones should wear brown eyeliner to enhance their eye color and complement their skin tone. Darker shades of brown can be used for a more dramatic look, while lighter shades are perfect for a natural everyday look.
Is brown eyeliner better for small eyes?
It can depend on the shade of brown you use. A light brown can make small eyes look bigger, while a dark brown eyeliner can make them look smaller. So it really just depends on what look you're going for!
Does brown eyeliner look natural?
Choosing an eyeliner in brown can definitely look natural if applied correctly, but it all depends on the shade and your skin tone. If you have light skin, go for a light brown eyeliner. If you have dark skin, go for a darker brown eyeliner. And as always, make sure to blend it well!
What eyeliner looks best on brown eyes?
There are a few different eyeliners that can look great on brown eyes. A dark brown or black eyeliner will make the eyes look more dramatic, while a lighter shade will add some brightness. Some people also like to use a brown liner on the lower lash line to make the eyes appear wider and more awake.
Does brown eyeliner make you look tired?
Any eyeliner can make you look tired if it is not applied correctly. If you don't use enough liner, it will just fade into your skin and disappear. But if you use too much, it will create a harsh line around your eyes that will be very noticeable and make you look tired. So be sure to use a light hand when applying brown eyeliner and blend it well into your skin.
Should you use brown eyeliner with blue eyes?
Blue eyes can wear brown eyeliner very well. Warmer tones of brown will work better with warmer shades of blue, while cooler shades of brown will work better with cooler shades of blue.
How do I choose the right eyeliner color?
When choosing an eyeliner color, it's important to take into account your eye color and the color of your clothes.
For example, if you have light-colored eyes, you might want to wear a black or brown eyeliner to make your eyes look darker. If you have dark-colored eyes, you might want to wear a light brown or beige eyeliner to make your eyes look brighter.
Does black eyeliner make you look older?
Black eyeliner can make you look older because it can be harsh against your skin and make your eyes look smaller.
If you're looking for a way to make your eyes look bigger and brighter, try using a lighter shade of eyeliner. You could also try using a darker shadow to line your eyes instead of eyeliner. This will give your eye contour more definition and make your eyes appear larger.
How do I choose brown eyeliner?
When choosing eyeliner in brown shades, you'll want to consider the consistency of the liner. Eyeliner comes in three main types- liquid, gel, and pencil.
Liquid liners are more pigmented and opaque than other types of liners. They're also the easiest to apply because they give you more control over the line thickness.
Gel liners have a creamy texture and are very easy to blend. They also last longer than other types of liners.
Pencil liners are easy to apply and last a long time and can be a bit more forgiving. Juvia's Place Nubian eyeliner pencil is a popular choice.
Should you put eyeliner on your lower lid?
Some people find that putting eyeliner on their lower lid makes their eyes look bigger and more awake. However, it's important to be careful not to go too heavy-handed with the eyeliner, as this can make your eyes look tired or overdone.
Bottom Line
We understand that it can be difficult and time-consuming to read through thousands of reviews online from verified customers. That is why we took the time to do it for you! We are excited that we could help you choose your next favorite beauty product.
So, go grab your new brown liner today, and create your new fabulous look! Thank you for taking the time to read our article. We appreciate you!
Check it out: